Inside vs Outside IR35: How Much Take-Home Pay Do You Lose?

Day rate examples for the 2026/27 tax year, and the inside IR35 rate you need to break even

Published Oct 27, 2026•By Mubarak, Software Developer & Marketing Specialist

The same day rate pays very differently depending on whether a contract is inside or outside IR35. This guide shows the gap at common UK day rates for 2026/27, explains where the money goes and shows how much more you need to charge inside IR35 to stand still.

Open the UK Contractor Take-Home tool

Disclaimer

The information on this page is for educational purposes only and does not constitute professional financial, tax, or legal advice. Please consult a qualified professional before making financial or business decisions.

The short answer

In 2026/27, a contractor on £500 a day for 220 days takes home about £65,730 inside IR35 through an umbrella and about £68,988 outside IR35 through a limited company that pays out all its profit, roughly £3,260 a year more outside. The main reason is that inside IR35 the 15% employer National Insurance comes out of your rate. To match the outside figure you need about £532 a day inside IR35.

What is the difference between inside and outside IR35?

Inside IR35 means HMRC treats you as an employee for tax, even though you work through an intermediary; outside IR35 means you are taxed as a business.

IR35 is the name contractors use for the intermediaries legislation. Under the off-payroll working rules, the client decides the status of each contract unless it is a small private sector business (see how to check your IR35 status). If the contract is inside, the fee paid for your work is taxed like a salary: income tax and employee National Insurance on the full amount, plus employer National Insurance paid by whoever runs the payroll. If it is outside, your limited company invoices the client, pays Corporation Tax on its profit, and you pay yourself a mix of salary and dividends.

In practice most inside-IR35 contractors are paid through an umbrella company, so the comparison that matters is umbrella PAYE against a limited company. That is what the UK contractor take-home calculator models.

How much do you take home inside and outside IR35 at common day rates?

Outside IR35 pays more at every day rate in the table below, but the gap is between about £1,900 and £5,100 a year rather than the five-figure differences contractors saw a few years ago.

Annual take-home, 220 days, England, 2026/27. Umbrella margin £20 a week with the Apprenticeship Levy. Limited company with £2,000 expenses, the best director salary and all profit paid as dividends.
Day rateInside (umbrella)Outside (Ltd)Gap a yearInside rate to match
£300£43,635£48,209£4,574£342
£400£54,683£58,598£3,916£436
£500£65,730£68,988£3,257£532
£600£73,943£78,995£5,052£667
£750£87,441£89,310£1,869£769

The gap is not a straight line. At £600 a day it widens because umbrella gross pay passes £100,000 and starts to lose the personal allowance, which creates an effective 60% income tax band between £100,000 and £125,140. The limited company keeps your personal income lower, so it avoids most of that taper. At £750 a day the company route hits the taper too, and its profits are taxed at the full 25% Corporation Tax for longer, so the gap closes again.

Measured as total tax (employer NI, levy, Corporation Tax, income tax, dividend tax and employee NI) against the contract value, the umbrella route costs 32.6% at £300 a day and 46.5% at £750. The limited company costs 23.9% and 44.7% at the same rates.

Why is inside IR35 take-home lower?

Inside IR35 you pay two layers of employment tax on almost all of the rate, and the employer layer comes out of your rate before your gross pay is set.

Employer National Insurance comes out of the assignment rate

From April 2025 employer National Insurance is 15% on pay above the secondary threshold of £5,000 a year, as set out in HMRC's rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (as of October 2026). Agencies usually quote an assignment rate that has to cover it, so the umbrella deducts it before working out your pay. On £500 a day that is about £13,519 a year.

Inside IR35 gross pay = (assignment income − margin − pension + £750) ÷ 1.155

The 1.155 divisor is 1 + 15% employer NI + 0.5% Apprenticeship Levy, and the £750 adds back the 15% that is not charged on the first £5,000. If your umbrella does not deduct the levy, divide by 1.15 instead. The umbrella company guide walks through a full payslip.

No expenses and no dividends

Inside IR35 you cannot deduct the costs a limited company would (accountant, equipment, insurance) from your taxable pay, and ordinary travel to the client site is not tax-deductible. All income is taxed as earnings at 20%, 40% or 45% plus employee NI of 8% (2% above £50,270), rather than as dividends at 10.75% or 35.75% with no NI.

What outside IR35 pays instead

The limited company pays Corporation Tax on its profit: 19% up to £50,000, 25% above £250,000 and marginal relief in between, which means profit between £50,000 and £250,000 is taxed at an effective 26.5%. Dividends are then taxed at 10.75% in the basic rate band and 35.75% in the higher rate band, after a £500 allowance (as of October 2026, per HMRC's income tax rates). Two layers again, but lighter ones.

Worked example: £500 a day for 220 days

On £110,000 of contract income, the umbrella route leaves £65,730 and the limited company leaves £68,988.

StepInside (umbrella)Outside (Ltd)
Contract income£110,000£110,000
Margin or business expenses£880£2,000
Employer NI£13,519£1,136
Apprenticeship Levy£476—
Gross pay / salary£95,126£12,570
Corporation Tax—£21,238
Dividends—£73,056
Income tax and dividend tax£25,482£16,639
Employee NI£3,913£0
Take-home£65,730£68,988
Per month£5,478£5,749

Inside IR35, gross pay is £95,126. Income tax is £7,540 on the basic rate band plus 40% of the £44,856 above it, giving £25,482. Employee NI is 8% of £37,700 (£3,016) plus 2% of £44,856 (£897).

Outside IR35, a £12,570 salary costs the company £1,136 of employer NI and leaves £94,295 of profit. Corporation Tax is 25% of that minus marginal relief of 3/200 × (£250,000 − £94,295), or £21,238. The £73,056 dividend uses £500 of allowance, £37,200 at 10.75% (£3,999) and £35,356 at 35.75% (£12,640).

What day rate do you need inside IR35 to match outside?

At the day rates above for 2026/27, you need between about 3% and 14% more inside IR35 to take home the same as a limited company that draws all its profit.

The last column of the first table shows the break-even rates: £532 inside to match £500 outside, £667 to match £600. If you leave profit in the company (see below), the outside figure is higher in long-run value and the uplift you need is larger. Use these numbers when an agency tells you a role has moved inside IR35 but offers the same rate, and see the freelance rate formula for building a rate from your costs instead.

  • Ask whether the quoted rate is an assignment rate (umbrella costs still to come off) or a PAYE rate (employer costs already paid by the agency). A £500 PAYE rate is worth far more than a £500 assignment rate.
  • Ask for the Key Information Document, which must show the deductions and your minimum gross pay.
  • Compare offers by take-home, not by headline rate. The calculator shows the inside rate needed to match automatically.

Does leaving profit in the company change the answer?

Yes. Most limited company contractors do not draw every pound, and money left in the company has only paid Corporation Tax so far.

At £500 a day, stopping dividends at the higher-rate threshold (£50,270 of total income) gives take-home of £46,271 this year and leaves £35,356 in the company after Corporation Tax. Added together that is £81,627 of value, against £65,730 inside IR35. The retained money is taxed again as dividends when you draw it, so the real advantage depends on drawing it in a lower-income year, into a pension, or on winding up the company. The director salary and dividends guide covers extraction in detail.

Employer pension contributions widen the gap further. Inside IR35 a salary sacrifice pension through the umbrella saves income tax and both kinds of NI. Outside IR35 the company pays the contribution from pre-tax profit, which saves Corporation Tax and later dividend tax, up to the £60,000 annual allowance (as of October 2026, per HMRC's annual allowance guidance).

How do Scotland and student loans affect the gap?

Scottish income tax widens the gap, because it applies to umbrella pay but not to dividends.

Scottish taxpayers pay 19% to 48% on earnings, with a 42% higher rate starting at £43,663 of income for 2026/27. Dividends are taxed at UK rates. At £500 a day for 220 days, a Scottish contractor takes home about £62,674 inside IR35 and the same £68,988 outside, so the gap rises to about £6,300 and the break-even inside rate to about £590.

Student loans reduce both routes. On Plan 2 (9% over £29,385), the same contract leaves about £59,814 inside and £63,926 outside. For a limited company director, dividends count towards the repayment only if they exceed £2,000 a year, and then in full.

Is outside IR35 always better?

On take-home it usually is, but inside IR35 through an umbrella gives you things a company director does not have.

  • Employment rights. An umbrella employee gets statutory sick pay, holiday pay, pension auto-enrolment and, where eligible, statutory parental pay.
  • Less admin. No company accounts, Corporation Tax return or director's payroll.
  • Less status risk. Outside IR35 your company carries the risk if HMRC later disagrees with a status decision made by your own company for a small client.

Sole traders are taxed differently again: at £500 a day, a sole trader takes home about £72,351 because there is no Corporation Tax layer. Many agencies will not engage sole traders, but if you have direct clients the limited company vs sole trader comparison is worth reading. For typical day rates by role, see UK freelance rates and average freelance rates, or work out your own rate with the freelance rate calculator.

Frequently asked questions

How much less do you take home inside IR35?

On the 2026/27 rules, a contractor billing £500 a day for 220 days takes home about £65,730 through an umbrella and about £68,988 through a limited company paying out all its profit, a gap of roughly £3,260 a year. The gap varies with the day rate, salary choice and how much profit you draw.

What day rate inside IR35 equals £500 outside IR35?

About £532 a day, assuming 220 days, a £20 weekly umbrella margin, £2,000 of company expenses and all company profit drawn as dividends. At £600 outside the equivalent inside rate is about £667.

Why is inside IR35 take-home so much lower than the day rate suggests?

Inside IR35 the umbrella pays 15% employer National Insurance above £5,000 a year, the 0.5% Apprenticeship Levy and its margin out of your assignment rate before your gross pay is set. You then pay PAYE income tax and employee NI on what is left.

Can I claim expenses inside IR35?

Mostly no. Inside IR35 you are taxed like an employee, so ordinary commuting to the client site is not tax-deductible, and the expenses that a limited company could deduct outside IR35 do not reduce your tax.

Has the outside IR35 advantage got smaller?

Yes. Employer NI rose to 15% with a £5,000 threshold from April 2025, and dividend tax rose to 10.75% and 35.75% from April 2026. Both reduce what a limited company contractor keeps.