How to Check Your IR35 Status
Who decides, what the tests look at, how CEST works and how to challenge a determination
Whether a contract is inside or outside IR35 can be worth thousands of pounds a year to a contractor. This guide explains who makes the decision under the off-payroll working rules, the employment status tests behind it, how HMRC's CEST tool fits in, what a status determination statement should contain, and what to do if you disagree.
Open the UK Contractor Take-Home toolDisclaimer
The information on this page is for educational purposes only and does not constitute professional financial, tax, or legal advice. Please consult a qualified professional before making financial or business decisions.
The short answer
For public sector clients and medium or large private sector clients, the client decides your IR35 status for each contract, must take reasonable care, and must give you a status determination statement (SDS) with its reasons. For small private sector clients, your own limited company decides. The decision rests on employment status tests such as control, substitution and mutuality of obligation; HMRC's free CEST tool gives a result HMRC will stand by if your answers are accurate. You can dispute an SDS, and the client must respond within 45 days.
What does IR35 status actually mean?
IR35 status says whether, ignoring your limited company, you would be an employee of the client for tax purposes.
If the answer is yes, the contract is “inside IR35” and the fees for your work are taxed like a salary. If no, it is “outside IR35” and your company is taxed as a business. Status is decided contract by contract, so you can hold an inside and an outside contract at the same time (as of October 2026, per HMRC's understanding off-payroll working). The rules are unlikely to apply if you are employed by an umbrella company, because you are already an employee there.
The money at stake is real. At £500 a day for 220 days in 2026/27, inside IR35 through an umbrella leaves about £65,730 against about £68,988 outside IR35 through a limited company paying out all its profit. The inside vs outside IR35 guide breaks that down.
Who decides whether a contract is inside IR35?
It depends on the client: public sector and medium or large private sector clients decide; for small private sector clients, your company decides.
| Client | Who decides | Who operates PAYE if inside |
|---|---|---|
| Public sector body | Client | The fee-payer (often the agency) |
| Medium or large private or voluntary sector | Client | The fee-payer (often the agency) |
| Small private sector | Your limited company | Your own company, under the original IR35 rules |
Is your client small?
A private sector company is medium or large if it meets two or more of the size conditions. HMRC's off-payroll working for clients page still lists turnover over £10.2 million, a balance sheet over £5.1 million and more than 50 employees. For financial years beginning on or after 6 April 2025 the turnover and balance sheet limits rise to £15 million and £7.5 million, with the 50-employee test unchanged. A company must meet the conditions for two consecutive financial years, and HMRC's Employment Status Manual (ESM10006A) says that for a usual 12-month year the earliest tax year affected is 2027/28 (as of October 2026). Some clients that count as medium today will become small then, and status decisions for those contracts will move back to you.
A small client must confirm its size if you or the party it contracts with asks. If it will not, ask in writing and keep the reply.
What tests decide IR35 status?
The same employment status tests the courts use: mainly control, the right to send a substitute and mutuality of obligation, plus several supporting factors.
| Factor | Points towards outside | Points towards inside |
|---|---|---|
| Control | You decide how, when and where the work is done | The client directs your day-to-day work and hours |
| Substitution | A genuine, unfettered right to send someone else, which you could use | You must do the work personally |
| Mutuality of obligation | Defined deliverables; no duty to offer or accept further work | Ongoing work given to you as it arises |
| Financial risk | Fixed prices, fixing mistakes at your own cost, own equipment | Paid for time regardless of results |
| Part and parcel | Treated as an outside supplier | Line management, staff benefits, internal email signature, staff events |
No single factor decides the outcome. What matters is the whole picture, and what actually happens day to day, not only what the contract says. A contract with a substitution clause that would never be accepted in practice adds little weight. HMRC's Employment Status Manual sets out how it reads each factor, starting at ESM0500.
How does HMRC's CEST tool work?
CEST (Check Employment Status for Tax) is a free, anonymous online questionnaire that gives an inside, outside or “unable to determine” result.
Anyone can use it: clients, workers, agencies and other third parties. It asks about who decides what work is done and when, where and how it is done, how you are paid, whether you get corporate benefits or expense reimbursement, and your responsibilities (as of October 2026, per HMRC's CEST guidance). You cannot save progress, so gather the contract and working details before you start.
- HMRC stands by the result as long as the information you give is accurate and in line with its guidance.
- It does not stand by contrived answers. HMRC treats arrangements designed to get a particular outcome as deliberate non-compliance.
- Re-run it when things change. If the contract or working practice changes materially, the old result no longer holds.
- “Unable to determine” is not covered by the stand-by promise; you need to look at the engagement against the Employment Status Manual or get specialist advice.
Clients are not obliged to use CEST, and many rely on contract reviews by specialists instead. Whatever method is used, the client must take reasonable care.
What must a status determination statement include?
An SDS must state the client's conclusion on your status and the reasons for it, and it must go to you and to the party the client contracts with.
According to HMRC's guidance for clients (as of October 2026), a client must decide the status of each worker and take reasonable care. If it does not give the reasons for its decision, the income tax and National Insurance become the client's responsibility. Clients must also keep records of their determinations, reasons, fees and any disagreements.
A useful SDS will:
- name the specific role and engagement, not a blanket decision for all contractors
- explain how control, substitution and the other factors were assessed
- say what evidence was used, such as a CEST result or a contract review
A blanket “all contractors inside” policy with no role-by-role reasoning is a weak basis for a determination and worth challenging.
How do you challenge an inside IR35 determination?
Write to the client setting out why you disagree; it must respond within 45 days, either confirming its decision with reasons or issuing a new one.
- Ask for the full SDS and reasons if you have not received them.
- Gather evidence of how the work actually happens: who sets tasks, whether you have sent or could send a substitute, how you are paid, your own equipment and insurance.
- Run CEST with accurate answers and keep the result.
- Send a written disagreement to the client. You or the deemed employer can do this at any point until the last payment for the engagement is made.
- Keep working under the original determination while you wait. If the client does not respond within 45 days, responsibility for the tax and NI moves to the client.
If the client upholds an inside determination, your options are to accept it and price accordingly, negotiate a higher rate, or decline the contract. Use the UK contractor take-home calculator to see the day rate you need inside IR35 to match your outside take-home, and read how umbrella companies work before you choose a payroll provider.
What should you do if your company decides status for a small client?
Treat it as seriously as a large client would: assess the contract, record your reasoning and keep evidence, because HMRC can challenge your company's decision later.
- Get written confirmation that the client is small.
- Review the contract and working practices against the factors above, and run CEST.
- Keep a dated file with the contract, the CEST result and any specialist review.
- Consider tax investigation insurance.
If the contract is inside IR35, your company must calculate a deemed payment and pay PAYE on it, which usually makes the limited company route no better than an umbrella. For outside contracts, the best director salary guide explains how to pay yourself. For setting a rate that covers these risks, see the freelance rate calculator, freelance pricing glossary and UK freelance rates.
Frequently asked questions
Who decides if a contract is inside IR35?
For public sector clients and medium or large private sector clients, the client decides and must give you a status determination statement. For small private sector clients, your own limited company decides.
Is the CEST tool reliable?
HMRC says it will stand by a CEST result as long as the information you enter is accurate and in line with its guidance, and the arrangement is not contrived. It will not stand by an outcome if the working arrangements change materially.
How long does a client have to respond to an IR35 dispute?
The client must respond within 45 days of receiving your disagreement, either confirming the determination with reasons or giving a new one. It keeps applying its original determination while it considers the dispute.
Can a contract be inside IR35 for one client and outside for another?
Yes. IR35 status is decided contract by contract, so the same contractor can hold inside and outside engagements at the same time.
Which companies count as small for IR35?
A private sector company is medium or large if it meets two or more of the size tests. For financial years starting on or after 6 April 2025 the tests are turnover over £15 million, balance sheet over £7.5 million and more than 50 employees, but HMRC says the change usually takes practical effect from the 2027/28 tax year.